ReCharge vs Bold vs Skio vs Smartrr, subscription provider pick for Magento coffee?

Four real options, real trade-offs:

• ReCharge, the default. Mature Magento + Shopify integrations, deep self-serve (pause / skip / swap / gift), best churn-prevention save-flows, deepest analytics. Pricing: 1% + $0.10 per transaction (Standard) or custom. Best for $500k, $10M coffee brands. ~80% of specialty coffee subs run on ReCharge.
• Bold Subscriptions, cheaper, simpler. Better for under $500k GMV. Magento integration is decent but the customer portal feels older. Pricing: 1% transaction fee or flat monthly.
• Skio, the new challenger. Headless-friendly, beautiful UX, modern Magento + Shopify integration, best-in-class “magic link” for subscriber self-serve (no password needed). Best for $1M, $10M brands that want a premium subscriber experience. Pricing: 1% + $0.20 per transaction.
• Smartrr, community-flavored. Built-in member-perks, bonuses, gamification. Best if your brand identity is community-led (think Cometeer-style). Pricing: 1% + $0.30 per transaction.

For Magento specifically: ReCharge has the deepest integration, Skio is rising fast for Hyvä headless setups. Bold is fine for small. Smartrr is a specific bet on community LTV. I default to ReCharge for any roaster under $5M GMV and Skio for $5M+ that’s rebuilding on Hyvä headless.